Do Loan Loss Reserves Behave like Capital? Evidence from Recent Bank Failures
نویسندگان
چکیده
Regulatory capital guidelines allow for loan loss reserves to be added back as capital. The evidence in this paper suggests that the influence of loan loss reserves added back as regulatory capital (hereafter referred to as “add-backs”) on bank risk cannot be explained by either economic principles underlying the notion of capital, or accounting principles underlying the recording of reserves. Specifically, we observe that in sharp contrast to the economic notion of capital as a buffer against bank failure risk, add-backs are positively associated with the risk of bank failure during the recent economic crisis. Further the positive association of add-backs with bank failure risk is concentrated among cases in which the add-backs are highly likely to increase a bank’s total regulatory capital. The evidence cannot thus be fully explained by accounting principles either, since the role of loan loss reserves according to those principles does not depend on whether the reserves generate a regulatory capital increase. Additional analysis suggests that the observed influence of loan loss reserves on bank failure risk may be an unintended consequence of their regulatory treatment as capital.
منابع مشابه
Loan Loss Reserves, Regulatory Capital, and Bank Failures: Evidence from the 2008-2009 Economic Crisis
This paper tests the influence of regulatory capital guidelines on the link between banks’ loan loss reserve decisions in 2007 and the risk of bank failure during the 2008-2009 economic crisis. Our primary finding is that larger loan loss reserve increases in 2007 are associated with an increased risk of bank failure in 2008-2009, but only for banks that are allowed to add back loan loss reserv...
متن کاملOptimal Capital Management in Banking
With the drafting of new banking regulation via the Basel II capital accord, bank regulatory capital and its adequacy has become the subject of much debate. In our contribution, we strive to construct a stochastic dynamic model to describe the evolution of bank capital that incorporates capital gains and losses. In our paper, such gains and losses are represented by loan loss reserves and the u...
متن کاملResearch on the Relationship of Commercial Bank’s Loan Loss Provision and Earning Management and Capital Management
This paper reviewed and analyzed the development of our nation’s loan loss provision system, then studied the relations of commercial bank loan loss provision and earnings management and capital management through empirical study. This paper selected 14 domestic commercial banks of year 2001-2009 as data sample, using Kanagaretnam et al.’s (2003) research method, dividing the loan loss provisio...
متن کاملDefending against speculative attacks when market opinions diverge
In a stylized continuous-time model of a small open economy with perfect capital mobility and a pegged exchange rate, I analyze an experiment in which domestic residents expect a future devaluation. Taking the public’s expectations as exogenous and allowing them to be divergent, I analyze in a short time period before the expected devaluation takes place how transactions of short-term collatera...
متن کاملEvidence on the Response of Us Banks to Changes in Capital Requirements
This paper develops a structural, dynamic model of a banking firm to analyse how banks adjust their loan portfolios over time. In the model, banks experience capital shocks, face uncertain future loan demand, and incur costs based on their proximity to regulatory minimum capital requirements. Non-linear relationships between bank capital levels and lending are derived from the model, and key pa...
متن کامل